Concept explainers
James sees an online ad for an at-home genetic test that promises to deliver personalized nutritional advice based on an individual’s genetic profile. The company can test for
Once the kits arrive, the family members use cotton swabs to take cell samples from their cheeks and place the swabs in individually labeled envelopes. They mail the envelopes back to the company, along with completed questionnaires regarding their diets. Four weeks later, they receive three individual reports detailing the test results and providing extensive guidelines about what foods they should eat. Among the results is the finding that James has a particular allele in a gene that may make him vulnerable to the presence of free radicals in his cells. The report suggests that he increase his intake of antioxidants, such as vitamins C and E, and highlights a number of foods that are rich in those vitamins. The tests also show that Sally has several genetic variations that indicate that she may be at risk for elevated bone loss. The report recommends that she try to minimize this possibility by increasing her intake of calcium and vitamin D and lists a number of foods she could emphasize in her diet. Finally, the report shows that Patty has a genetic variation that may mean that she has a lowered ability to metabolize saturated fats, putting her at risk for developing heart disease. The report points to ways in which she can lower her intake of saturated fats and lists various types of foods that would be beneficial for her.
A number of companies now offer genetic-testing services, promising to deliver personalized nutritional or other advice based on people’s genetic profiles. Generally, these tests fall into two different categories, with individual companies offering unique combinations of the two. The first type of test detects alleles of known genes that encode proteins that play an established role in, for example, counteracting free radicals in cells or in building up bone. In such cases, it is easy to see why individuals carrying alleles that may encode proteins with lower levels of activity may be more vulnerable to free radicals or more susceptible to bone loss.
A second type of test examines genetic variations that may have no clear biological significance (i.e., they may not occur within a gene or may not have a detectable effect on gene activity) but have been shown to have a statistically significant correlation with a disease or a particular physiological condition. For example, a variation may frequently be detected in individuals with heart disease even though the reason for the correlation between the variation and the disease may be entirely mysterious.
Do James and Sally have any guarantees that the tests and recommendations are scientifically valid?
To determine: Whether the tests and recommendations suggested by the company about genetic variations are scientifically valid.
Introduction: Nowadays, a large number of private companies offer genetic-testing services. These companies promise to deliver specific nutritional advice on the basis of an individual’s genetic profile.
Explanation of Solution
According to the given case, Mr. J, his wife (Ms. S), and their daughter (Ms. P) took an at-home genetic test. The company that tested for genetic variation provided them a report after the test. The report showed that Mr. J had a particular allele in a gene that may make him vulnerable to the presence of free radicals in the cells.
The test also showed that Ms. S had several genetic variations that indicate the risk of elevated bone loss. Moreover, the report also showed that Ms. P had a genetic variation which may lower the ability to metabolize saturated fats. This genetic variation put Ms. P at the risk of developing heart disease.
There is no guarantee that the test and recommendation provided by the company (that test for genetic variations) are scientifically valid. The companies that offer a test for genetic variations do not provide any proof that the trained medical professionals give the test results. Also, a second opinion of a health professional is essential to validate these test results.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 15 Solutions
Human Heredity: Principles and Issues (MindTap Course List)
- Human Anatomy & Physiology (11th Edition)BiologyISBN:9780134580999Author:Elaine N. Marieb, Katja N. HoehnPublisher:PEARSONBiology 2eBiologyISBN:9781947172517Author:Matthew Douglas, Jung Choi, Mary Ann ClarkPublisher:OpenStaxAnatomy & PhysiologyBiologyISBN:9781259398629Author:McKinley, Michael P., O'loughlin, Valerie Dean, Bidle, Theresa StouterPublisher:Mcgraw Hill Education,
- Molecular Biology of the Cell (Sixth Edition)BiologyISBN:9780815344322Author:Bruce Alberts, Alexander D. Johnson, Julian Lewis, David Morgan, Martin Raff, Keith Roberts, Peter WalterPublisher:W. W. Norton & CompanyLaboratory Manual For Human Anatomy & PhysiologyBiologyISBN:9781260159363Author:Martin, Terry R., Prentice-craver, CynthiaPublisher:McGraw-Hill Publishing Co.Inquiry Into Life (16th Edition)BiologyISBN:9781260231700Author:Sylvia S. Mader, Michael WindelspechtPublisher:McGraw Hill Education