3 Improving Huckel Theory for Ethene Huckel theory uses a set of very strong approximations on the matrix elements of the Hamiltonian. Let's examine how we might improve these approximations for a simple conjugated molecule like ethene. For all calculations that follow you can use a = -11.4eV and B = -2.8eV. (A) Explain all fundamental assumptions of Huckel theory relative to the fully accurate solution that would be obtained by Hartree-Fock theory. (B) In reality, the calculation for the orbital overlap between 2pz orbitals on the carbon atoms of ethene comes out to ~ 0.27. Using this value of the overlap matrix and the Hamiltonian assumptions you stated in (A) calculate the total π-electron energy of ethene. How different is this result from the plain Huckel theory result for ethene? (C) Use Extended Huckel theory (Hij = ½½ * 1.75 * Sij * (Hii + Hjj)) to calculate the matrix elements Hij using what you have calculated from (B). Using these matrix elements, as well as the overlap matrix elements in the previous question, calculate the new total π-electron energy of ethene and compare it to your previous answers. (D) Assuming that each Carbon atom has an effective nuclear charge of Z = 3.25, write down the full electronic Hamiltonian for ethene accounting for only the T-electrons. How does the Hamiltonian you wrote down relate to the matrix elements a and ẞ appearing in Huckel theory. (E) Does the Huckel theory wavefunction obey all postulates of quantum mechanics? Explain your answer. If it violates any of the postulates, explain mathematically how you would correct Huckel theory.

Introduction to Chemical Engineering Thermodynamics
8th Edition
ISBN:9781259696527
Author:J.M. Smith Termodinamica en ingenieria quimica, Hendrick C Van Ness, Michael Abbott, Mark Swihart
Publisher:J.M. Smith Termodinamica en ingenieria quimica, Hendrick C Van Ness, Michael Abbott, Mark Swihart
Chapter1: Introduction
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 1.1P
icon
Related questions
Question

Please do not rely too much on chatgpt, because its answer may be wrong. Please consider it carefully and give your own answer. You can borrow ideas from gpt, but please do not believe its answer.Very very grateful!Please do not rely too much on chatgpt, because its answer may be wrong. Please consider it carefully and give your own answer. You can borrow ideas from gpt, but please do not believe its answer.

and and Very very grateful!

3 Improving Huckel Theory for Ethene
Huckel theory uses a set of very strong approximations on the matrix elements of the Hamiltonian. Let's examine
how we might improve these approximations for a simple conjugated molecule like ethene. For all calculations that
follow you can use a = -11.4eV and B = -2.8eV.
(A) Explain all fundamental assumptions of Huckel theory relative to the fully accurate solution that would be
obtained by Hartree-Fock theory.
(B) In reality, the calculation for the orbital overlap between 2pz orbitals on the carbon atoms of ethene comes out
to ~ 0.27. Using this value of the overlap matrix and the Hamiltonian assumptions you stated in (A) calculate the
total π-electron energy of ethene. How different is this result from the plain Huckel theory result for ethene?
(C) Use Extended Huckel theory (Hij = ½½ * 1.75 * Sij * (Hii + Hjj)) to calculate the matrix elements Hij using
what you have calculated from (B). Using these matrix elements, as well as the overlap matrix elements in the
previous question, calculate the new total π-electron energy of ethene and compare it to your previous answers.
(D) Assuming that each Carbon atom has an effective nuclear charge of Z = 3.25, write down the full electronic
Hamiltonian for ethene accounting for only the T-electrons. How does the Hamiltonian you wrote down relate to
the matrix elements a and ẞ appearing in Huckel theory.
(E) Does the Huckel theory wavefunction obey all postulates of quantum mechanics? Explain your answer. If it
violates any of the postulates, explain mathematically how you would correct Huckel theory.
Transcribed Image Text:3 Improving Huckel Theory for Ethene Huckel theory uses a set of very strong approximations on the matrix elements of the Hamiltonian. Let's examine how we might improve these approximations for a simple conjugated molecule like ethene. For all calculations that follow you can use a = -11.4eV and B = -2.8eV. (A) Explain all fundamental assumptions of Huckel theory relative to the fully accurate solution that would be obtained by Hartree-Fock theory. (B) In reality, the calculation for the orbital overlap between 2pz orbitals on the carbon atoms of ethene comes out to ~ 0.27. Using this value of the overlap matrix and the Hamiltonian assumptions you stated in (A) calculate the total π-electron energy of ethene. How different is this result from the plain Huckel theory result for ethene? (C) Use Extended Huckel theory (Hij = ½½ * 1.75 * Sij * (Hii + Hjj)) to calculate the matrix elements Hij using what you have calculated from (B). Using these matrix elements, as well as the overlap matrix elements in the previous question, calculate the new total π-electron energy of ethene and compare it to your previous answers. (D) Assuming that each Carbon atom has an effective nuclear charge of Z = 3.25, write down the full electronic Hamiltonian for ethene accounting for only the T-electrons. How does the Hamiltonian you wrote down relate to the matrix elements a and ẞ appearing in Huckel theory. (E) Does the Huckel theory wavefunction obey all postulates of quantum mechanics? Explain your answer. If it violates any of the postulates, explain mathematically how you would correct Huckel theory.
Expert Solution
steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

Blurred answer
Recommended textbooks for you
Introduction to Chemical Engineering Thermodynami…
Introduction to Chemical Engineering Thermodynami…
Chemical Engineering
ISBN:
9781259696527
Author:
J.M. Smith Termodinamica en ingenieria quimica, Hendrick C Van Ness, Michael Abbott, Mark Swihart
Publisher:
McGraw-Hill Education
Elementary Principles of Chemical Processes, Bind…
Elementary Principles of Chemical Processes, Bind…
Chemical Engineering
ISBN:
9781118431221
Author:
Richard M. Felder, Ronald W. Rousseau, Lisa G. Bullard
Publisher:
WILEY
Elements of Chemical Reaction Engineering (5th Ed…
Elements of Chemical Reaction Engineering (5th Ed…
Chemical Engineering
ISBN:
9780133887518
Author:
H. Scott Fogler
Publisher:
Prentice Hall
Process Dynamics and Control, 4e
Process Dynamics and Control, 4e
Chemical Engineering
ISBN:
9781119285915
Author:
Seborg
Publisher:
WILEY
Industrial Plastics: Theory and Applications
Industrial Plastics: Theory and Applications
Chemical Engineering
ISBN:
9781285061238
Author:
Lokensgard, Erik
Publisher:
Delmar Cengage Learning
Unit Operations of Chemical Engineering
Unit Operations of Chemical Engineering
Chemical Engineering
ISBN:
9780072848236
Author:
Warren McCabe, Julian C. Smith, Peter Harriott
Publisher:
McGraw-Hill Companies, The